Ukraine and its neighbours, explained

Advertisement

Home › Opinion › Iran's admission and the Flight 752 aftermath

Opinion

Iran's admission and the Flight 752 aftermath

Summary

A look back at the days after the downing of a Ukrainian airliner near Tehran, when denial gave way to admission and vigils turned into protests.

What happened between the crash of Ukraine International Airlines Flight 752 and the moment Tehran admitted responsibility? By 15 January 2020, the sequence was already clear, and it showed how quickly a official denial could collapse.

The flight, a Boeing 737-800 on the Tehran to Kyiv route, was shot down by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps shortly after takeoff on 8 January 2020. All 176 people on board were killed.

From denial to admission

On 9 January, U.S., Canadian, British and Iraqi officials said they believed the plane had most likely been brought down accidentally by an Iranian anti-aircraft missile. Iran said the cause was mechanical failure. The same day, the New York Times released a verified video, obtained from an Iranian citizen, showing the plane being struck by what appeared to be a surface-to-air missile.

Canada's Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, was cautious in his public remarks that day. He said it was too early to draw definitive conclusions that the downing was an act of war, and he condemned Iran's attack on U.S. bases in Iraq. On 10 January, after Trudeau suggested an Iranian missile had downed the aircraft, Iranian authorities rejected the idea. The country's civil aviation chief said he was certain no missile had hit the plane and still pointed to mechanical failure.

That position lasted only until 11 January. On that date the Revolutionary Guard admitted it had mistakenly shot down the aircraft as it took off from Tehran, and Iran's president formally acknowledged that the armed forces had erroneously hit the Ukrainian plane with a missile near the capital.

Vigils become protests

The admission did not close the matter inside Iran. Vigils held for the victims turned into protests on 11 January. Videos posted on Twitter showed hundreds of protesters in Tehran calling for the resignation of Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

The same day, the British ambassador to Iran, Robert Macaire, was arrested during the demonstrations, after attending a vigil and then, according to the BBC, getting a haircut. Tasnim News Agency said he was held on suspicion of organising, provoking and directing radical actions. The UK Foreign Secretary, Dominic Raab, called the arrest a flagrant violation of international law. Macaire was released more than an hour later.

What the sequence showed

The timeline is short: a crash on 8 January, foreign officials pointing to a missile on 9 January, public video evidence the same day, a renewed denial on 10 January and a full admission on 11 January. Within those four days, Iran's account moved from mechanical failure to a military error acknowledged at the highest levels.

For Ukraine, whose national carrier lost the aircraft and the people aboard, the central fact was the confirmation that the plane had been shot down. For Iran's leadership, the admission was followed at once by public anger on the streets of Tehran, and by a diplomatic incident involving a British envoy. The episode also placed Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom and Iraq among the governments that publicly voiced their assessment before Tehran changed its position.

The chain of events left a clear record of how the explanation shifted, and of how much pressure came from outside evidence and from public mourning at home.

Related analysis